On a recent trip to the US, as I was at the gate awaiting my flight, I ran into Mr. Smith, a parent from a school at which I served as Head of School. It was great to see him, and we immediately began talking about his family and particularly about his son, Amos, who was a student of mine in Advanced Placement Physics BC (a college level course which I was privileged to teach).
At the beginning of the school year, Amos showed a real interest in the physics, asking many questions in class and interacting in a lively manner.
As the class went on, however, I began to notice he dropped off on his homework and had difficulty getting his lab reports in on time. This is a real problem for me, since I required homework to be turned in every day, covering the material we had covered the previous day.
Amos’s mother and I communicated frequently on the phone about this issue. She supervised his homework every evening with little effect. Even though he completed it in front of her, he would frequently forget to turn it in or lose it altogether before class the next day. This was an almost nightly occurrence.
Amos was hit and miss on biweekly summative assessments; he could handle many of the problems that had been assigned, but not all. He also seemed to understand what was happening in lab, but again, Amos had difficulty turning them in fully completed.
Mrs, Smith and I continued to work together to try an help Amos keep up in class, but as we continued through the year, it became more and more apparent Amos had a different way of learning and processing. For example, he was the only one in class who never took a note during the class discussion. He always listened intently, but never wrote anything down. It make me wonder how much he was really grasping.
By the end of semester one, he had the lowest grade in class, a “D,” mostly related to the daily assignments he was missing. He really stood out among his classmates, who were perfect in the homework, as they were the most able kids in the Senior Class.
As college acceptances began to arrive, there was considerable concern in Amos’ family because of his low grade and study habits in my class. His parents and I were in constant dialogue trying to figure out a way to help Amos.
Finally, one morning when I came to school, I noticed Amos sitting against the locker in Senior Hallway helping his classmates solving the physics problems that were due that morning. The incongruity stuck me immediately: how was he helping others with the most challenging problems, while he couldn’t (didn’t) turn in his own homework?
It became more and more obvious to me Amos learned a different way than the other kids in my class. So I finally (duh!) altered the way I would assess him homework, since he had a different way of learning physics.
That day, I asked if Amos if he would be willing to select the most difficult problem of the day and help his classmates through the problem at the very beginning of the class (that was usually my job). We agreed that if he would do this, I would give him full credit for completing the homework for the day. Amos agreed and never looked back!
When I met Amos’ dad at the airport, all these memories came flooding back. I was so interested to learn what had become of Amos after leaving High School. How did he handle the demands of college and what was he doing for a career?
I was gratified to learn of the next installment! I discovered Amos had received a “4” on the Advanced Placement Physics Exam, one of the highest grades in the class. Yes, he had graduated from High School and had received an acceptance to an excellent four year college where he chose physics as his major and completed his course successfully. Since he wanted to apply his love for physics in a practical manner, he also applied and was accepted to Harvard Business School, where he graduated with his MBA. Finally, he was offered a position with a start-up high tech firm in Austin, Texas, where he was enjoying his career immensely.
I was so excited and impressed to hear of Amos’ wonderful success; I was also reminded of the way in which God has gifted each of us in a different ways to meet the diverse needs and opportunities in our exciting world!
Thanks be to God!